Fixed vs. Expansion Mounted Bearings: What Aggregate Operations Need to Know

Fixed vs. Expansion Mounted Bearings: What Aggregate Operations Need to Know

Conveyor, motor, bearings, conveyor belt moving aggregate gravel

A conveyor pulley bearing can match the shaft diameter, housing, and bolt pattern and still be the wrong replacement. If an expansion bearing is replaced with a fixed bearing, the shaft loses its intended path for axial growth. As the equipment warms, the bearing may begin running hot even though everything appears to fit.

Before ordering a mounted bearing, you need to know which position should locate the shaft, which should allow movement, and what application conditions determine the difference.

Fixed and Expansion Bearings Share the Work

A shaft supported by two mounted bearings often needs the bearing positions to perform two different functions. Both support the shaft radially, but one fixes its axial position while the other allows controlled axial movement. 

The fixed bearing, also called the locating or non-expansion bearing, supports radial load, carries the applicable axial locating load, and holds the shaft in its intended axial position. It establishes the point from which relative shaft growth is accommodated. 

The expansion bearing, also called a floating or non-locating bearing, supports the shaft radially while allowing the bearing insert to move axially within the housing. It doesn’t mean the locking device is loose on the shaft.

Axial float also isn’t the same as angular self-alignment. A spherical roller bearing can handle some angular misalignment while remaining axially fixed in its housing.

Choosing the fixed and floating positions is only part of the bearing decision. Our guide to axial vs. radial loads in mounted bearings explains how radial load, thrust, and combined loading affect bearing selection and service life. 

Use Relative Growth to Decide When the Shaft Needs to Float

Two fixed bearings aren’t automatically wrong. You can use fixed units at both ends when the shaft and supporting framework are both steel and stay close to the same temperature, keeping their difference in expansion small.

A two-fixed-bearing arrangement is most practical on shorter, thermally stable shafts. If the original equipment manufacturer designed the machine with two fixed positions, don’t change it based on a general rule.

Check whether the shaft needs an expansion bearing when the application has:

  • A long distance between bearing supports
  • A shaft that runs hotter or colder than its supporting frame
  • Different shaft and frame materials
  • Multiple bearing positions along one shaft
  • A heated process, such as a kiln or asphalt operation
  • A fan, conveyor pulley, crusher, or other application with a meaningful shaft-to-frame temperature difference

There isn’t a universal shaft-length cutoff. A long shaft operating at a steady temperature may have less relative movement than a shorter shaft next to a heat source. What matters is how much the distance between bearing positions along the shaft changes relative to the supporting structure. 

Ambient temperature alone doesn’t answer that. The relevant temperature difference is between the shaft and the structure supporting the bearings.

Even a Fraction of an Inch Needs Somewhere to Go: Relative Growth Example Calculation 

For a simplified example, steel expands or contracts approximately 0.0000063 inch per inch for every 1°F change in temperature. Consider a 10-foot bearing span where the steel shaft operates 100°F hotter than the supporting steel frame:

120 inches × 0.0000063 × 100°F = approximately 0.076 inch

That’s slightly more than 1/16 inch of relative growth. It may not look like much, but two fixed bearings leave no available place for that movement. Once the available clearance and structural flexibility are used up, the growth can create unwanted axial loads in the bearings and housings.

This calculation illustrates the scale of the movement, not a universal threshold for using an expansion bearing. The required arrangement depends on the bearing span, materials, shaft-to-frame temperature difference, mounting arrangement, and permitted direction of movement.

Restricted Movement Leaves Clues, Not Proof

IBT specialists commonly check the fixed-and-expansion arrangement when they find a broken housing, a bearing that heats up as the machine reaches operating temperature, or a problem that began after a bearing replacement.

Those signs don’t prove the shaft is trapped. Incorrect lubrication, contamination, misalignment, excessive load, loose hardware, and structural problems can create similar symptoms. Our guide to the common causes of mounted bearing failure in aggregate and mining covers those possibilities in more detail.

Instead of relying on one damage pattern, verify the equipment drawing, part numbers, bearing positions, and current physical configuration. This is especially important if the unit may have been converted in the field.

Pick the Fixed Position Before the Floating One

In most horizontal arrangements, the fixed bearing is placed near the motor, gearbox, coupling, or sheave. That keeps the drive end of the shaft axially located while thermal growth moves toward the expansion bearing.

It isn’t a universal rule. Some equipment must maintain the axial position of an impeller, seal, gear, or other shaft-mounted component. In those applications, the fixed position may be selected around that component and the required direction of shaft movement. 

The fixed position determines where the shaft remains axially located and where the resulting movement is accommodated. Loads, couplings, shaft-mounted components, equipment orientation, and required clearances can all affect that choice. 

Application Note: The steps below provide general guidance and aren’t a complete bearing-selection procedure. Final selection should account for the equipment design, loads, speed, temperatures, shaft and frame materials, mounting arrangement, operating environment, and applicable OEM and bearing manufacturer instructions. 

Before selecting the expansion unit:

  1. Check the OEM Arrangement: Start with the equipment drawing, bill of materials, or maintenance manual.
  2. Identify Components That Require Axial Location: Note the drive components, fan wheels, impellers, seals, and other parts whose position must be maintained.
  3. Determine the Growth Direction: Establish which direction the shaft should move as its temperature changes.
  4. Check the Axial Loads: Make sure the fixed bearing has sufficient rated axial capacity for the applicable load.
  5. Verify the Available Float: Ensure the expansion unit provides enough axial movement in the required direction.

When relative expansion must be accommodated on a shaft with several solid-block bearing positions, use one fixed unit and allow the remaining positions to float.

Timken Solid-Block Bearings Add Strength and Flexibility

Timken Family Mounted Bearings

Once you know which position should be fixed and which should float, Timken solid-block mounted spherical roller bearings make that arrangement easy to manage.

Each unit combines a rugged, one-piece cast-steel housing with a double-row spherical roller bearing. Multiple locking and sealing options help match the bearing to conveyors, fans, crushers, vibrating equipment, and other aggregate applications exposed to heavy loads, shock, dirt, and moisture.

A major benefit is that Timken solid-block units can be changed between fixed and floating configurations in the field. Float is set at the housing with an external retaining nut without modifying the method used to lock the bearing to the shaft. The ability to convert a unit from fixed to floating gives maintenance teams more options when stocking replacements. 

For demanding aggregate service, the value goes beyond expansion capability. Customers get excellent spherical roller bearing capacity, a strong cast-steel, one-piece housing, sealing options for dirty environments, and the flexibility to switch between fixed and floating arrangements when needed. Our article on Timken solid-block mounted spherical roller bearings covers the broader housing, locking, and sealing options.

Don’t Confuse the E Suffix With Type E

In Timken solid-block mounted spherical roller bearing nomenclature, no letter in the fixed-or-expansion position identifies a fixed unit. An E identifies an expansion, or floating, unit.

That suffix shouldn’t be confused with Timken Type ESA, which is a separate mounted tapered roller bearing product family. Timken’s self-aligning Type ESA mounted tapered roller bearings are also available in fixed and expansion configurations. 

Match the Conversion to the Housing

Timken solid-block bearings use an external housing nut to establish float. Depending on the housing, the unit can move in one or both directions.

Orientation is especially important with flange units. When a flange bearing is converted to expansion, the bearing insert can float only toward the retaining nut, so the nut must face the required movement direction and sit opposite the fixed bearing. 

Follow the instructions for the exact housing and locking style in the Timken solid-block mounted spherical roller bearing catalog.

Safety Note: Before inspecting, adjusting, or converting a mounted bearing, shut down the equipment and block it against hazardous motion. At surface metal and nonmetal mines, 30 CFR 56.14105 requires shutting off power and blocking machinery against hazardous motion before repairs or maintenance begin. When movement is necessary for an adjustment or test, personnel must be effectively protected from hazardous motion. 

Bring What You Know, and We’ll Help With the Rest

A part number is helpful, but it may not tell the full story. A unit could have been converted after installation, and two bearings with matching dimensions may perform different jobs on the same shaft.

If available, bring us:

  • Complete part numbers and photos of both bearing positions
  • The shaft diameter and distance between supports
  • The equipment type, drive location, and operating speed
  • Shaft and frame materials and temperatures
  • Housing and mounting details
  • Load information, equipment drawings, or failure history

Don’t worry if you don’t have everything on the list. Even a part number, equipment description, and a few clear photos can help us get started.

If you’re not sure whether a bearing position should be fixed or floating, our aggregate and mining specialists can help you work through the arrangement, determine the required float, and find the right Timken solid-block option.

Timken solid block mounted tapered roller bearing is shown.

Shop Timken Expansion Bearings Online

Check out ShopIBT.com to find the bearing and power transmission products for your needs!

Share:

Contact IBT Industrial Solutions

Phone # (913) 428-2858
QUESTIONS?

Newsletter Signup!

Our Expertise in Your Inbox: Subscribe to our PrimeMover newsletter and never miss any of our tips, tricks or latest product innovations.

Nachi

Recent News

Get in touch for help and information

Our head office address:

9400 W 55th St, Merriam, KS 66203

Call for help:

(913) 428-2858